5-STAR GOOGLE REVIEWS
How to prove fault in a Dog Bite case
If you need legal assistance concerning a Dog Bite case, don’t hesitate to contact Raymon Law Group at (505) 390-1040 located in Albuquerque, New Mexico.
RAYMON LAW GROUP
How Our Personal Injury Attorney Can Help
Dog Bite incidents can have severe consequences, leading to physical injuries, emotional trauma, and financial burdens. In Albuquerque, NM, dog bite victims need to be aware of the complexities of proving fault to ensure they receive fair compensation. At Raymon Law Group, we understand the challenges you face, and our dedicated team is here to support you through these difficult times.
If you need legal assistance concerning a Dog Bite case, don’t hesitate to contact us at (505) 390-1040, conveniently located in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Our dedicated team is here to support you through challenging situations, ensuring that your rights and interests are skillfully advocated for and protected.
The Importance of Establishing Liability
Proving fault in a Dog Bite Case requires a thorough understanding of New Mexico’s liability laws. Unlike some states that follow a “one-bite rule,” New Mexico adheres to a strict liability standard. This means that a dog owner can be held liable for injuries caused by their dog, regardless of whether the dog had previously shown aggressive behavior.
Strict Liability in Dog Bite Cases
Under New Mexico Law, Dog Owners are held strictly liable if their dog bites someone, provided the victim was lawfully present on the property and did not provoke the dog. This principle simplifies the process for victims seeking compensation but still requires solid evidence to support the claim.
Comparative Negligence and Its Impact
New Mexico also follows a Comparative Negligence Rule. This means that if the victim is found partially at fault for the incident, their compensation may be reduced by their percentage of fault. For instance, if a victim is found to be 20% responsible for the bite, their compensation will be reduced by 20%. Therefore, it is crucial to minimize any potential blame attributed to the victim.
Key Elements to Prove Fault in a Dog Bite Case
Establishing Ownership of the Dog
To hold someone accountable for a dog bite, you first need to prove who owns the dog. This can be established through various means:
Witness Statements: These are testimonies from individuals who saw the incident. They can confirm the presence of the dog and its owner at the scene. Witnesses can include neighbors, passersby, or anyone else who observed the dog and its owner before, during, or after the attack.
Animal Control Records: These are official records maintained by local animal control authorities. They can provide documented evidence linking the dog to its owner, including prior complaints or incidents involving the dog. This documentation can show a history of ownership and any previous aggressive behavior.
Veterinary Records: These documents include the dog’s medical and vaccination history, which can trace the dog back to its owner. Veterinary records often have the owner’s contact information and can confirm that the dog is regularly taken to a specific veterinary clinic, establishing a connection between the dog and the owner.
Proving the Victim's Lawful Presence
To hold the dog owner liable, the victim must show that they were lawfully present on the property when the bite occurred. This can be demonstrated by:
Invitations: If the victim was invited to the property, whether verbally or in writing, this confirms their lawful presence. Invitations can come from the dog owner or other residents of the property.
Public Property: If the incident occurred in a public place, such as a park or sidewalk, the victim’s lawful presence is typically clear. Public spaces are areas where individuals have a right to be, and dog owners must control their pets in these areas.
Delivery or Service Personnel: Individuals performing their duties, such as mail carriers or delivery drivers, are considered lawfully present while on the property. These workers have a legal right to be on the premises to perform their jobs.
Demonstrating the Lack of Provocation
Proving that the victim did not provoke the dog is crucial in a Dog Bite Case. This can be supported by:
Witness Statements: Bystanders who saw the incident can provide accounts confirming that the victim did not provoke the dog. These statements can describe the victim’s actions and the dog’s behavior leading up to the bite.
Surveillance Footage: Video recordings from security cameras or nearby businesses can objectively show the events leading up to the bite. Footage can provide a clear, unbiased perspective on whether the victim’s actions were provocative.
Medical Records: Expert analysis of the injuries can help determine if they are consistent with an unprovoked attack. For instance, certain bite patterns or injury locations might indicate a sudden, unprovoked attack rather than a defensive bite in response to provocation.
Gathering and Preserving Evidence
Medical Documentation
After a dog bite, immediate medical attention is essential for health reasons and to create a record of the injuries.
Emergency Room Reports: These provide initial assessments and treatments. They document the severity of the injuries and the immediate medical response.
Photographs of Injuries: Visual evidence of the wounds, taken immediately after the incident and throughout the healing process. Photographs can show the progression of injuries and the extent of scarring or permanent damage.
Medical Bills: Detailed statements of all medical expenses incurred due to the bite. This includes costs for hospital stays, medications, surgeries, and any other treatments.
Witness Testimonies
Witnesses who saw the dog bite can provide crucial evidence. It’s important to gather:
Detailed Statements: Comprehensive descriptions of what witnesses observed during the incident. These statements should cover the events before, during, and after the bite.
Contact Information: Ensuring witnesses can be contacted later for further testimony if needed. Witnesses might need to be reached for depositions or court appearances.
Incident Reports
Filing an official report with local authorities or animal control is essential. Incident reports typically contain:
Detailed Descriptions: A thorough account of the incident, including the date, time, location, and circumstances of the bite.
Owner and Dog Information: Key details about the dog and its owner, including any history of aggression. This information helps establish the owner’s responsibility and any previous incidents involving the dog.
Expert Testimony
Experts can provide additional credibility to your case. Expert testimony might include:
Behavioral Analysis: Insights from animal behaviorists about the dog’s behavior and potential causes of the attack. This can explain whether the dog’s actions were typical or if there were specific triggers.
Medical Expertise: Opinions from medical professionals on the nature and severity of the injuries. Medical experts can describe how the injuries were sustained and their long-term impact on the victim.
Legal Strategies for Proving Fault
Leveraging Strict Liability
New Mexico’s strict liability laws mean dog owners are automatically responsible for bites if certain conditions are met. The focus should be on:
Proving Ownership: Establishing that the defendant owns the dog. This involves gathering evidence that directly links the dog to the owner.
Lawful Presence: Demonstrating that the victim was lawfully on the property when the bite occurred. This can be shown through evidence of an invitation, public property presence, or the victim performing their job duties.
No Provocation: Showing that the victim did not provoke the dog. This requires evidence that the victim’s actions were non-threatening and that the bite was unprovoked.
Utilizing Precedent Cases
Previous court rulings in similar dog bite cases can provide valuable support. Precedent can:
Strengthen Legal Arguments: Use previous rulings to reinforce your claims. By referencing similar cases where courts ruled in favor of the victim, you can bolster your argument for strict liability.
Predict Judicial Outcomes: Understand how courts have ruled in comparable situations to anticipate potential outcomes. This helps in formulating a strategy that aligns with judicial tendencies in dog bite cases.
The Role of an Experienced Dog Bite Attorney
An Experienced Attorney is essential in navigating the complexities of a dog bite case. At Raymon Law Group, our skilled Personal Injury Attorneys provide comprehensive support and strategic legal representation.
Conducting Thorough Investigations
Our attorneys will meticulously investigate the incident by:
Collecting Evidence: Gathering all relevant medical records, witness statements, and incident reports. This involves detailed scrutiny of all available documentation.
Analyzing Reports: Reviewing official reports from authorities and animal control to understand the full scope of the incident.
Consulting Experts: Working with medical and behavioral experts to strengthen your case. Expert opinions can provide a deeper understanding of the incident and its impact.
Negotiating with Insurance Companies
Insurance companies often aim to minimize payouts. Our team will:
Secure Fair Settlements: Advocate for compensation that covers medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. We ensure that the settlement reflects the full extent of your damages.
Manage Communications: Handle all interactions with insurance adjusters to protect your interests. This prevents you from making statements that could harm your case.
Representing You in Court
If a fair settlement cannot be reached, we are prepared to:
File a Lawsuit: Initiate legal proceedings to pursue compensation through the court system.
Present a Strong Case: Utilize collected evidence and expert testimony to advocate on your behalf in court. We present a compelling argument to ensure you receive the compensation you deserve.
Compensation Available in Dog Bite Cases
Victims of dog bites may be entitled to various forms of compensation to address their injuries and associated costs. The compensation typically includes:
Medical Expenses
Coverage for medical expenses may include:
Emergency Care: Costs of initial treatment and hospitalization. This covers emergency room visits, surgeries, and immediate medical attention required after the bite.
Rehabilitation: Expenses for physical therapy and other recovery treatments. Rehabilitation is often necessary for long-term recovery and to regain full functionality.
Future Medical Needs: Anticipated costs for ongoing and future medical care. Some injuries may require extended treatment, including follow-up surgeries or continuous therapy.
Lost Wages
If the injury results in the victim being unable to work, compensation can cover:
Lost Income: Reimbursement for time missed from work due to the injury. This includes wages lost during the recovery period
Loss of Earning Capacity: Compensation for any long-term impact on earning potential. If the injury affects the victim’s ability to perform their job or reduces their capacity to earn in the future, they may be compensated for this loss.
Pain and Suffering
Non-economic damages for pain and suffering may be awarded for:
Physical Pain: Compensation for the physical pain experienced due to the injury. This includes chronic pain, discomfort, and any ongoing physical challenges resulting from the bite.
Emotional Distress: Damages for emotional trauma and mental anguish. Dog bites can lead to psychological impacts such as anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Contact Raymon Law Group Today
Proving fault in a Dog Bite case in Albuquerque, NM, requires a thorough understanding of the law, meticulous evidence gathering, and strategic legal action. At Raymon Law Group, we are committed to helping dog bite victims navigate these complexities to achieve fair compensation.
If you or a loved one has been bitten by a dog, don’t hesitate to contact us at (505) 390-1040. Conveniently located in Albuquerque, New Mexico, our dedicated Personal Injury team is here to support you through challenging situations, ensuring that your rights and interests are skillfully advocated for and protected.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the first step I should take after a dog bite?
The first step after a dog bite is to seek immediate medical attention to ensure your injuries are properly treated and documented. Next, report the incident to local animal control authorities and gather as much evidence as possible, including photographs of your injuries, witness statements, and information about the dog and its owner. This documentation will be crucial for building your case.
Who can be held liable in a dog bite case?
The dog owner is typically held liable for a dog bite. In some cases, other parties may also be responsible, such as a landlord who knew about the dog’s aggressive behavior but failed to take action. To determine liability, it’s essential to consult with an experienced dog bite attorney who can evaluate the specifics of your case.
How does New Mexico’s strict liability law affect my case?
New Mexico’s strict liability law means that dog owners are automatically held responsible for bites if the victim was lawfully on the property and did not provoke the dog. This law simplifies the process of proving fault since it removes the need to prove the owner’s negligence. However, you must still demonstrate the basic elements of your case, such as ownership of the dog and your lawful presence.
What if the dog has no prior history of aggression?
Under New Mexico’s strict liability law, a dog owner can still be held liable even if the dog has no prior history of aggression. The law focuses on the fact that the dog bit someone, regardless of its past behavior. This makes it easier for victims to seek compensation without needing to prove the dog’s history of aggressive behavior.
How can witness testimonies help my case?
Witness testimonies provide crucial firsthand accounts of the incident, supporting your version of events. Witnesses can describe the circumstances leading up to the bite, the behavior of the dog and its owner, and confirm that you did not provoke the dog. Their statements can significantly strengthen your case by adding credibility and corroborating your claims.
Practice Areas
Free in-depth No Obligation Case Evaluation
Arrested?
We never Stop Fighting for Our Clients.
Looking for Personal Injury Attorney New Mexico? Contact New Mexico Trial Attorney
Our Reviews
Free in-depth No Obligation Case Evaluation
100% Confidential
No Fee, Unless
We are Successful for you
